Top Guidelines to Help Choosing the Best Driving Instructor

driving instructor

As 17 and 18 year olds head back to school, college or university, for many an important mark of independence is to learn to drive. But global pioneer of telematics-based car insurance provider, Insure The Box, is urging teenagers and their parents to think very carefully about their choice of driving instructor as Department for Transport data shows a 4.1% decline in driving instructors with Approved Driving Instructor (ADI) status. This reduction between March 2015 and March 2016 is a continuation of the 14.4% decrease since March 2012.

Approved Driving Instructor (ADI) status

“Driving is a life skill, but it’s something parents often entrust to a complete stranger,” says Simon Rewell, Road Safety Manager for Insure The Box. “It’s essential, therefore, that parents and teenagers find a driving instructor they are comfortable with and can trust to give the highest level of tuition. It should be about much more than the price and how quickly they can learn and take the test. And with less driving instructors with ADI status, parents and teenagers need to be even more vigilant.”

Anyone who is paid to teach someone to drive must either be an Approved Driving Instructor (ADI) with an A or B ‘ADI standards check’ grade or be a Trainee Driving Instructor. In order to qualify as an ADI, instructors are marked on 17 areas of competence which are grouped into three areas: lesson planning, risk management and teaching and learning. They can then display a badge in their windscreen to prove they’re registered with the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency.

A green badge means they’re a fully qualified instructor and a pink badge means they’re a trainee instructor. A trainee instructor is permitted to teach at a driving school, but the customer should be informed before booking lessons. Any driving instructor should be punctual, arrive in a clean, well-maintained car and have a prepared lesson plan, based on the Driving Standards Agency (DVSA) syllabus.

“We recommend that anyone learning to drive should look for an instructor with an A or B Grade qualification and ask them to bring their certificate to the first lesson,” continued Simon Rewell. “A Grade A indicates the highest standard of instruction, whereas a Grade B is competent.”

Sue Duncan, General Secretary for Advanced Driving Instructors, adds: “Choosing a driving instructor is a very important decision for learners and parents. With focused lessons from a qualified instructor, younger drivers should develop good driving habits that stay with them for life.

“It’s tempting to think about cost first, but quality tuition plays a vital role in helping to cultivate safe, confident drivers who don’t take unnecessary risks once they pass their test.”

Insure The Box’s Guide to Finding a Good Driving Instructor


All driving instructors must be an Approved Driving Instructor (ADI), or a Prospective Driving Instructor (PDI) before they can charge for their services. This means they have been tested and registered by the Driving Standards Agency (DSA, now DVSA). However, you can get free tuition by anyone of the age of 21 who has held a full licence in the class you are learning for at least three years.

There is no law saying you must use an ADI, but it is advisable because free tuition will come from people who will pass their bad habits on to you. Approved Driving Instructors often have vehicles with dual controls, too, which means that they can brake for you if they feel you are in danger.

Approved Driving Instructors

Approved driving instructors must display an octagonal green badge in their windscreen; trainee driving instructors (PDIs) must display a triangular pink badge in their windscreen.

Driving instructors are graded with either A, B and Fail. Grade A means a mark of 85% or more and Grade B means a mark of 60% or more.


You are free to choose a driving instructor of either gender, depending on your preference. If you feel more comfortable with a female instructor, choose a female instructor; if you prefer a male instructor, choose a male instructor. If you want one where you’re not too sure because it’ll be a good story for your grandkids, good luck with that…


If English isn’t your first language you can find an instructor that speaks your native language. Although, if you’ve got this far in this guide, you probably have a good enough grasp of English.

Lesson materials

All lessons should be derived from DVSA instructional material. The instructor might also provide separate materials such as worksheets, DVDs or other study aids. Find out if these are provided as part of the fees, or whether they’re extra.


Meet with a few driving instructors to interview them and see which one suits you best. You will be looking to have some rapport (connection) with the instructor as continuing lessons with someone you don’t like will give you a bad first experience of driving.

Type of vehicle

Learning to drive in a manual vehicle will give you more options. However, if you only want to drive automatic vehicles, you can choose an instructor with an automatic.

If you are very tall there are cars that might be difficult for you to fit in, so try out the instructor’s car for size before you commit to a lesson. Similarly, if you are very short, or you are disabled in some way that prevents you from reaching or operating the pedals you may need to find an instructor who can accommodate your physical requirements.


Sticking to a regular time slot is preferable for an instructor because he or she can block those slots for you over several weeks. The instructor should be able to meet you at a place that is convenient for you, and will be reliable and punctual.


It is preferable for you not to choose on price. Cheaper instructors might be cheaper for a reason – they’ve discounted their prices because they have a poor reputation or poor results. You might end up having to re-sit your test or pay for extra lessons, in which case going for a cheap instructor is a false economy.

Ask if the instructor will provide the first lesson free or at a discount. Some will give a full lesson, some will give a taster (shorter) lesson, and others won’t.

Bear in mind that you might need to have up to 80 hours of lessons, depending on your natural aptitude, your ability to learn and the quality of instruction, so be sure that this is within your budget.

Make sure you know the cancellation policy. Some instructors are lenient on cancellations where others will expect to be paid if the lesson isn’t cancelled within a certain time before it is due. We would say that if you book a lesson and cancel any less than 48 hours before the lesson, you have a moral obligation to pay for that lesson unless the instructor can fill it. Being a driving instructor is a job and they need to earn money, too.

Lesson structure

Find out how long the lesson will be. Instructors will tend to want to offer longer lessons because this minimises their wasted driving time between students. If they suggest two hours, this can be quite long for a novice driver and it could be too tiring. You will need to assess how you feel. Some instructors recommend you start with one hour for the first few lessons then build up to two hours as you gain confidence, while other instructors recommend you dive in and start with two hours because you can cover a wider range of driving experiences (this is especially relevant if you live in a central city area and need to get out for rural driving, and vice versa).

Ask the instructor whether they pick up other drivers while you are still on your lesson. This can be distracting for you and the instructor, however, it does make it more practical for the instructor because the instructor can have the other student drive you home. This might make it slightly cheaper as the instructor then doesn’t waste time driving between clients. This is called piggy-backing and, while being practical for the instructor, it is frowned upon.

Finding an instructor

Reviews and social proof

Ask around to find out who is the best instructor in your area. Look at reviews on online review websites (though, be aware that it’s easy to make fake reviews, both good and bad).

Using Directgov

Use Directgov’s postcode-based search to find an instructor near you, or if you’re in Ireland you can use this site. For example if your postcode is PE22 0SL (which was mine when I was growing up), enter that into the form, click ‘Find Nearest’ and you’ll see a list of local Approved Driving Instructors  – name, phone, email address and distance from your location. If the email address looks like it’s a personalised website (i.e. not a Yahoo, Hotmail or Gmail address), you can probably deduce their website so you can check that out before calling.

Independent driving instructor, or a driving school?

Some drivers work independently and you will deal with them directly. Others work as part of a school with several drivers. Make sure to talk directly with the driving instructor that you will use to make sure you feel comfortable.

Independent driving instructor

Remember that you can be taking practical driving lessons while you are also using our website to learn your theory. An instructor will help you with any areas that you find difficult, giving you real-world examples in a driving situation. To practice the theory tests, click on the links for car, motorbike, HGV or PCV tests at the top of this page.

Related posts

Leave a Comment